Insights/Guides

Online reputation management software: what to check before you buy

Eight checks for choosing reputation software, with a cost worksheet, published vendor prices, review rules by market and sales call questions.

Thinkiyo team··12 min read

Buy reputation software when you have more locations, channels or mentions than one person can read, and when you can name who will act on what it finds. Before signing, test it on your own data, get a three-year total in writing, and read the renewal clause. Most tools look alike in a sales call. The differences show up when a complaint needs another team, when the AI writes something wrong, or when the renewal notice arrives.

Do you need it yet?

Probably not, if you have one location and a handful of reviews a week. A shared inbox and a spreadsheet will do, and our guide to running the process by hand shows how. Software starts to pay when you have several locations or channels, when replies are being missed, or when the same complaint keeps returning and nobody can say how often.

Write down three things before you take a call: every place your customers post, who can fix each type of complaint, and what you spend today in staff hours.

What products cost

Published prices as of November 2026, in US dollars where the vendor shows them. Many vendors don't publish, and prices can vary by region, so treat these as a starting point.

VendorPublished priceUnitNote
Reputation$80, $115, $150 per monthPer locationCustom for 125 or more locations. Ticketing, social and premium sources listed as add-ons
BirdeyeNot publishedForm asks location countTerms set out 90 days' notice and an 8% renewal fee unless your contract differs
Zendesk$19 to $115 per agent per month, billed annually. Suite Enterprise is quote onlyPer agent plus AIHelpdesk, included for comparison. See our Zendesk and Freshdesk post
Freshdesk$19 to $89 per agent per month, billed annuallyPer agent plus AI sessionsHelpdesk. Omni plans cost more
RelayQuoted on a callScoped by channels and volumeDivisions can be bought separately

Notice the units. A per-location tool punishes a retailer with 300 sites. A per-agent tool punishes a large team with a handful of sites. Model both using your own numbers.

Six product checks

1. Does it cover where your customers really talk?

List your channels first and ask about each by name. Which are included, which cost more, and which can be read but not answered? Markets differ. A vendor's country list can show text review requests or reporting limited to certain countries. WhatsApp is charged by Meta per delivered message, with rates by category and country, and India and Brazil have their own rates. LINE plans vary by country or region, with separate pages for Japan, Taiwan and Thailand. WeChat has a 48-hour reply window for businesses, as documented by Zendesk.

2. Can a complaint reach someone who can act?

Ask the vendor to show a one star review becoming a task for your payments or delivery team, then the outcome coming back. If that step relies on copy and paste, it will be skipped on a busy day.

3. Can you see where an AI reply came from?

Ask for a draft and the policy it used. Then ask what stops a reply about refunds going out without a person approving it. Ask how to turn automation off by channel.

4. Does it understand your customers?

Don't accept a general accuracy figure. Give the vendor 50 of your own real mentions, including sarcasm and any languages your customers mix, such as Hinglish, Arabic and English, or Spanish and English. Compare its reading with your team's.

5. Do alerts explain themselves?

An alert should say which theme moved, on which channels and how far above normal. Ask how many alerts a business your size would get in a week. Too many and people stop reading.

6. Will the reports change a decision?

Look for complaint causes by location or team, reply times by channel, and how many public complaints went unanswered. A sentiment chart alone rarely tells you what to fix.

The rules your tool must respect

This is general information. Rules depend on your facts and market, so check your own and take advice where it matters.

The principle that holds nearly everywhere: reviews must be genuine, you may not pay for a particular opinion, and you may not hide unfavourable ones. Google's policy applies in every market where you have a profile. It bars incentives for a review or for changing one, and it says businesses must not "discourage or prohibit negative reviews, or selectively solicit positive reviews from customers". Replies also get checked before they appear. Google says this usually takes up to 10 minutes and sometimes up to 30 days.

MarketWhat to knowSource
USRule in force since 21 October 2024. Covers fake reviews, insider reviews, review suppression. Incentives may not require or imply a particular sentimentFTC, 16 CFR 465
UKGuidance warns against suppressing genuine reviews or selectively promoting them, and sets a duty to take reasonable and proportionate steps. Fake reviews remained an enforcement focus in October 2026CMA208, CMA blog
AustraliaFake or misleading reviews are unlawful. Removing genuine negative reviews can mislead. Past court penalties are listedACCC
EUWe could not open the text for this post. Start with Directive 2019/2161 and your national regulatorEUR-Lex
IndiaWe could not open a primary source on review rules. Personal data rules were notified in November 2025 with an 18-month phased timelineShardul Amarchand Mangaldas

Practical test for any vendor: if a review-request flow asks "how did we do?" and only sends happy customers to Google, that is the pattern the rules above warn about. Ask to see the flow and whether it can be turned off.

Data location matters too. Birdeye states hosting on AWS in the United States. Zendesk offers a selectable region on higher plans, and Freshdesk lists US, EEA, UAE, India and Australia data centres. For transfer rules, see the European Commission and Australia's OAIC. Your market may have its own.

Two commercial checks

7. How do you leave?

Contracts vary a lot, even among well-known vendors. As of November 2026:

VendorNotice to stop renewalAt renewalExport after the end
Birdeye90 days8% fee unless your contract differsWe did not find a stated period
Zendesk30 daysMay apply then-current rates30 days
Freshworks30 daysFees adjusted, notified at least 30 days before14 days from closure

Your order form can override all of these. Small businesses in some markets have extra protection. Australia, for example, has penalties for unfair terms in standard form contracts with small businesses. Ask a lawyer if a term looks one-sided.

Put the notice date in your calendar on the day you sign.

8. What will the real bill be?

LineOption AOption BOption C
Unit count in year 3 (locations, seats)
Base subscription, year 1
Add-ons you saw in the sales call
Premium review sources
AI usage: volume x unit price
SMS, WhatsApp, other message charges
Setup and training
Weekly staff hours x hourly cost x 52
Uplift in years 2 and 3
Exit cost: export, overlap, retraining
Three-year total

A made-up example, not a real business. Lucía runs 30 cafes in Mexico and Spain and is pricing a per-location tool at $115 a month: 30 x $115 x 12 is $41,400 a year. Adding 8 stores in year two takes the year to $52,440. Add any uplift, add-ons and message charges, and the three-year figure is the one to take to finance.

Questions for the sales call

  1. What is the three-year total, in writing, using my real numbers?
  2. Which features shown today are in the plan you quoted?
  3. What is the notice period, and how do I give notice?
  4. Is the renewal price capped?
  5. Which of my countries are fully supported, feature by feature?
  6. Which channels can I reply to from the product?
  7. What can the AI send without a person?
  8. Where is my data hosted and processed?
  9. What can I export, in what format, and for how long after I leave?
  10. Can I speak with a customer of a similar size, in my market, who has renewed?

Ask vendors to answer by email. It keeps the promise on the record.

Migration and data export

If you are replacing a tool, check this before giving notice.

  • Export reviews, cases, tags, reports and templates, and open every file. Birdeye describes an Excel review download. Zendesk says exports must be enabled by request. Freshdesk warns that its ticket export omits full conversations and archived tickets.
  • Keep a list of every profile and who holds admin access.
  • Carry over review-request opt-outs before anything sends.
  • Rebuild the templates you use, and drop the rest.
  • Plan a period where both tools run, and set a clear end date.

How to run a fair trial

Use your own data and the people who'll use it each day. Pick a set period and compare replies sent, time taken and how often AI drafts needed changing. Include one awkward test: a refund complaint in a public review, in the second language your customers use. Speak to a current customer of a similar size, and ask what surprised them.

SituationOwnerDo firstNever
Vendor offers a deadline discountBudget holderAsk for the total and the renewal capSign in that call
AI draft makes up a policySupport leadRecord it and stop that automationAccept "it will learn" with no fix
Tool can't reply on a key channelChannel ownerConfirm the platform limit in writingAssume it's coming soon
Hosting location is unclearPrivacy leadGet the region and processors in writingSign and check later
Trial data looks better than real volumeProject ownerRe-test on a busy weekReport the trial number as the result

Messages you can copy

Names, dates and numbers in these messages are placeholders.

Opening email to a vendor:

We have 22 locations in Dubai, Toronto and Bengaluru and about 900 reviews a month. Before a call, please send your price basis, notice period, renewal terms and which of those countries are fully supported.

Trial request:

We'd like to test on 50 of our own mentions, in English and Arabic, with our team scoring the results. Is that possible before we discuss pricing?

Following up:

I asked for the written total last Tuesday. Our shortlist closes on Friday, and we can only include vendors who have sent one.

Decision to a vendor you didn't choose:

Thanks for your time, Tomasz. We went with another option because it covered our markets at a lower three-year total. Please remove our trial data and confirm when that's done.

The hard case, when legal or finance says no:

We can't accept a 90-day notice period. If 30 days isn't possible, we need a written reminder 120 days before renewal, or we'll have to step back.

A plan for Monday

Timings are a suggested starting point, not a benchmark.

  1. Day 1: List channels, owners, and current tools with renewal dates.
  2. Week 1: Pull 50 real mentions and mark what should have happened.
  3. Week 2: Shortlist three vendors. Email them the questions.
  4. Week 3 and 4: Run trials on real data.
  5. Week 5: Fill in the worksheet with written quotes.
  6. Week 6: Decide, and write the notice date in the calendar.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Buying for the sentiment dashboard when the need is getting complaints fixed.
  • Comparing per-location and per-seat prices without modelling both.
  • Trusting a feature list without checking your country.
  • Trialling on the vendor's sample data.
  • Letting automation reply about refunds with no approval.
  • Forgetting the exit until the renewal notice arrives.

What to measure

Baseline these before you buy, then review them at 90 days as a suggested checkpoint.

  • Share of public complaints answered, by channel.
  • Time to first reply on negative reviews, by location.
  • Share of negative mentions that became a case with an owner.
  • How often AI drafts were edited before sending.
  • Repeat complaints on the top three themes.

It's working when repeat themes fall and someone can name what was changed. If only the reply count goes up, you have a faster reply machine.

What runs in Relay today

Relay Reputation puts reviews and public posts in one queue with email and messaging. Each item is a ticket with an owner and SLA clock. Replies are drafted for a person to approve, and a person stays on every refund. Crisis alerts name the theme and explain the score. It can run in your own cloud.

Limits. Each channel needs its own connection before replies go out. App Store and Play Store replies stay in the developer console. Quora and news are read only, and classification accuracy hasn't been benchmarked, so test it on your own mentions as in check 4. Plans are quoted on a call, and you can contact us with your list of channels.

Related: comparing Birdeye and Reputation and answering every Google review.

Common questions

Is reputation software the same as social listening?

They overlap. Social listening finds and analyses mentions, and reputation software usually adds review management and replies. Check which of those you need.

Should it connect to our helpdesk?

If support complaints arrive in reviews or public posts, yes. Otherwise your support and brand teams can end up answering the same customer separately. Ask to see the handover on your own data.

How much does reputation software cost?

Some vendors publish per-location prices, such as Reputation at $80 to $150 per location per month as of November 2026, and others only quote. Add-ons, message charges and renewal uplifts move the total. Use the worksheet for a three-year figure.

Can AI reply to reviews on its own?

Many tools offer it, and whether you should depends on the review. Keep a person on anything involving money, safety or a legal claim. Check Google's policies too, since replies are reviewed before they are published.

Google's policy prohibits selectively soliciting positive reviews, and regulators in several markets treat hiding genuine negative reviews as a problem. The exact rule depends on your market. Ask all customers, and check your own regulator's guidance.

Sources

See what Relay can do for your customer service

Get a personalised 30 minute demo on your own channels and policies. We show you Relay handling your real conversations, then set it up with you.

  • Built and connected for you
  • Can run in your own cloud
  • A person on every refund

Brands we work with

  • Bolt
  • Dave & Buster's
  • ETV Win
  • Malachite Cars
  • Space Angel
  • Infinity Quest
Made by Thinkiyo© 2026 Thinkiyo. Relay is a Thinkiyo product.Examples use Lumen Parcel, a fictional brand.