Chloe M.Google reviewOrder arrived damaged and nobody has replied to my email in three days.

Online reputation management is three jobs: find what people say about your business, answer the things worth answering, and fix what keeps causing complaints. A small team can start on Monday with a spreadsheet. Two rules hold almost everywhere. Never fake, buy or quietly bury reviews. Never treat the reply as the fix.
The research is more useful than the slogans, and less flattering.
In the best known study, Proserpio and Zervas compared hotels on review sites where they could respond with sites where they rarely did. Hotels that started responding gained about 0.12 stars and about 12% more reviews. They received fewer negative reviews, and the ones they did receive were longer. The authors suggest unhappy guests write fewer short, hard-to-defend complaints once they expect a reply.
Chevalier, Dover and Mayzlin found something less comfortable. Managerial responses increased reviewing activity, and especially negative reviews. The authors suggest people write partly to reach the manager. Replying can bring you more criticism. That is useful if you read it.
Why bother with a tenth of a star? Luca's Harvard working paper used restaurant tax data from Washington State and found a one-star rise on Yelp lifted revenue by 5 to 9%, for independents only. Chains showed no effect. All of this is hotels and restaurants, so treat it as a direction, and test it on your own numbers.
Most businesses leave the opportunity on the table. A vendor study by UENI, which sells websites to small businesses, looked at 229,882 Google reviews and found owners replied to 9.8% of one-star reviews and 29.3% of five-star ones. One-star replies took 19.5 days on average. It covers UENI's own customers, so it is a signal and no more.
The principle is close to universal: reviews must be real, connections and rewards must be disclosed, and you can't hide the bad ones. The detail varies. This is general information and depends on your circumstances. Check your own market, and ask a lawyer before relying on it.
| Market | What the rule says | Worth knowing |
|---|---|---|
| US | The FTC Consumer Review Rule bans fake reviews, paying for a particular sentiment, undisclosed insider reviews and suppressing reviews through threats. In force since 21 October 2024. | Up to $53,088 per violation as of December 2025, for knowing violations. No specific ban on asking only happy customers, but the FTC says it could violate the FTC Act. |
| UK | DMCC Act 2024, Schedule 20, paragraph 13 bans fake reviews and hidden incentives, in force since 6 April 2025. Publishers must take reasonable and proportionate steps to prevent and remove them. | The CMA guidance warns against offering a refund or gift card to change a review, and against making dispute resolution depend on not leaving a negative one. |
| EU | Traders must say how they check reviews are genuine and can't alter reviews or pay for fake ones. | National enforcement differs. |
| Australia | The ACCC says creating or arranging fake reviews is against the law, and removing genuine negative reviews may mislead. | Meriton was ordered to pay A$3 million in 2018 for stopping likely complainers getting TripAdvisor's review prompt. |
| India | IS 19000:2022 sets principles for collecting, moderating and publishing reviews. Reported as voluntary at launch in November 2022. | Check whether it has since become mandatory for your sector. |
| Canada | The Competition Bureau says employees must disclose connections to the business they review, and those who allow misleading reviews may be liable. | Applies even when the review is honest. |
| Singapore | The CCCS treats posting a fake review as an unfair practice under the Consumer Protection (Fair Trading) Act. | Loft Home Furnishing gave undertakings in June 2024. |
Platform rules sit on top. Google's policy bars incentives for reviews, discouraging negative reviews and selectively asking for positive ones. A review only comes down if it breaks Google's policies. Disagreeing with it isn't enough.
Spend an hour looking at your business the way a customer would.
That last line is your baseline. Keep it.
List every place customers talk about you, who has the login and how often someone checks. A spreadsheet is enough. Most of the failures you are about to prevent live in the gap between tools: reviews in one dashboard, social in another, email somewhere else.
Name one owner. Write down how fast you will respond on each channel, and who steps in for money, safety and legal issues. The targets below are a suggested starting point, not a benchmark. Change them to what your team can keep.
| Situation | Who owns it | Do first | Never |
|---|---|---|---|
| Praise | Community or store manager | Thank them for something specific, within 3 working days | Paste the same line on every review |
| Service complaint with a clear fix | Support | Reply in public within 1 working day, move details private | Ask for an order number in public |
| Refund or payment dispute | Payments owner | Acknowledge, confirm who is checking, within 1 working day | Promise an amount before checking |
| Review that may be fake | Reputation owner | Check your records, then report it | Accuse the reviewer of lying without proof |
| Safety, health or legal threat | Senior manager plus legal | Hold statement within 2 hours, take the facts offline | Argue the facts in public |
| One theme climbing across channels | Comms lead | Agree one line, tell the frontline | Reply to each post in a different voice |
One page is enough. Cover what you can promise, what never goes in public, how you sound when you are sorry, and when you take it private. Add one line on privacy: no order numbers, addresses or account details in a public reply.
Here are five you can adapt. Fill the brackets.
First reply to a complaint:
Hi [name], I'm sorry about [the specific thing]. I'm [your name] and I'm looking at it now. I'll get back to you by [time] with what happens next.
Public reply:
[Name], that's not what you paid for. We've found the issue with [general description] and want to put it right. Please message us at [private channel] so we can sort out the details away from here. [Your name]
Update when there is no news:
[Name], no answer yet from [team or courier]. I've chased them today and will update you by [time], even if nothing has changed.
Closing reply:
[Name], [the fix] is done. If anything still looks wrong by [date], reply to this and it comes straight back to me. Thanks for sticking with it.
The hard one, when the reviewer is wrong:
Hi [name], we looked into this and our records don't match what's described here: [one neutral fact, nothing private]. We'd still like to understand what happened. Please contact [name or address] and I'll go through it with you.
Say it once. If they reply angrily, stop in public and keep the offer open.
Businesses tend to do the opposite, as UENI's numbers show. Clear the last 90 days from the lowest rating up. Write each one by hand if the backlog is small. If you use a template, change at least the first line.
Don't reply to reviews that are several years old unless they are still high in the listing. A two-year-late apology draws attention and helps nobody.
Tag each complaint by cause, such as late delivery, billing or staff. Count them monthly. Take the top cause to the person who can change it, with three real examples.
This is the part that changes your reputation. Replies manage what has happened. Only a fix reduces what gets written next.
Write the plan before you need it. Agree who decides, who writes the hold statement and who briefs the frontline. Then watch for one theme running higher than normal across channels. The outage worked example shows the sequence.
Track a few numbers weekly, and only ones you can act on.
It is working when unanswered complaints fall, and the top cause shrinks within a quarter. If replies go up and the same cause stays on top, you are managing the damage and leaving the source running.
If you outgrow the spreadsheet, Relay pulls reviews, social mentions and email into one queue with a category, urgency, owner and SLA clock. Money and safety topics route to a person, and nothing goes out until a person presses send. Spikes in a theme raise alerts in Relay and Slack, and reopen rate is computed from ticket history.
The limits: Google Business, X, Meta and similar channels each need a connection token. App Store and Play Store replies still go through each store's console. Drafts come from rules per category and need a person's edit, because reading your policy documents into each draft is not wired up yet. See how it works, our software buyer's guide, or contact us.
You can report a review that breaks the platform's rules, such as spam or a conflict of interest. On Google, only reviews that violate policy are eligible for removal, and evaluation typically takes several days. A review that is simply negative usually stays, so answer it well.
Reply to every complaint and most specific praise. The research supports responding, though one study found responses can also bring more negative reviews. Volume alone is a poor goal, so favour replies that fix something or say something true.
Rules differ by market and platform. Google prohibits incentives, the UK requires any incentive to be disclosed, and the FTC rule allows incentives when no sentiment is required, while warning that failing to disclose them could violate the FTC Act. The simplest global policy is to offer nothing.
Not at first. A single location can run this with a shared inbox and a spreadsheet. Software starts to pay when you have several locations or channels, or too many mentions to read by hand.
Check your records first, then report it with the reason. You can also respond in public with one neutral sentence. The ACCC says to have an adequate basis before treating a review as fake, which is sensible anywhere.
GuidesIntroducing Relay: your online reputation in one placeWhat Relay is, the gap it was built for, what it does today, what it does not do yet, and who should choose something else.29 October 2026 · 6 min read
GuidesHow to automate customer support without trapping your customersWhat to automate, what to keep with a person, what the law says about AI disclosure, and how to tell whether automation is really working.9 November 2026 · 12 min read
GuidesOnline reputation management software: what to check before you buyEight checks for choosing reputation software, with a cost worksheet, published vendor prices, review rules by market and sales call questions.9 November 2026 · 12 min readGet a personalised 30 minute demo on your own channels and policies. We show you Relay handling your real conversations, then set it up with you.
Brands we work with


