Insights/Compare

A Birdeye alternative for online reputation management

How to compare Birdeye, Reputation and Relay: published prices, renewal terms, data export, a cost worksheet and when to stay put.

Thinkiyo team··11 min read

If your main job is getting more reviews and keeping listings accurate across many locations, Birdeye or Reputation may well be the right tool, and you should read the section on staying before you switch. Look elsewhere when the review is the easy part and the hard part is getting the complaint behind it to someone who can fix it. Before either decision, read the renewal clause. As of November 2026, Birdeye's terms ask for 90 days' written notice to stop an auto renewal and add an 8% fee at renewal unless your contract says otherwise.

What the vendors publish

All details below are from each vendor's own pages as of November 2026. Check them again on the day you buy.

BirdeyeReputation
Public priceNone. The pricing page is a form that asks for your location count$80, $115 or $150 per location per month, custom for 125 or more locations
What sets the priceDescribed as what you deploy at your locations, with "one contract"Location count and plan
Sold as extrasAsk for the list in writingActions and Ticketing, Social Suite, Competitive Insights, Premium Sources such as Yelp and Tripadvisor
HostingAWS in the United StatesWe did not find a published location. Ask
Sources200+ review sitesPremium sources are an add-on

Reputation's page shows dollar prices and doesn't state a billing term or regional rates, so ask for both. Birdeye's quote may differ by market, and its own country list matters more than the headline product list. As of November 2026 it says text review requests work in the US, Canada, Australia, Mexico, Puerto Rico and the UK, and reporting is supported in the US, UK and Australia. If you trade in Jakarta, Dubai or Sao Paulo, get your market confirmed in writing.

Birdeye's messaging page lists text, Facebook, Instagram, email and voicemail in one inbox. We could not confirm WhatsApp availability by country from a page we could open, so ask if WhatsApp is how your customers reach you.

The clause to read first

Birdeye's terms, effective 13 May 2026, say three things every buyer should know:

  • An agreement auto renews for the same length as the first term unless written notice reaches Birdeye at least 90 days before renewal, unless the order form says otherwise.
  • From agreements made on or after 1 April 2024, unless your contract changes it, an 8% Innovation Fee applies to recurring fees at each auto renewal.
  • Payment obligations under an order form are non-cancellable and payments are non-refundable, except where the terms say otherwise.

Auto renewal is common, and Zendesk and Freshworks both do it on 30 days' notice as of November 2026. Your order form can change any of this. The risk is finding out on day 91. Put the notice date in two calendars the day you sign.

Total cost worksheet

Fill this in for each vendor, using written quotes.

LineVendor AVendor BRelay or other
Locations or seats you will really have in year 3
Year 1 subscription
Listings, social, ticketing, surveys, if extra
Premium review sources, if extra
Messaging charges (SMS, WhatsApp)
Setup and training
Staff hours per week x hourly cost x 52
Renewal uplift in years 2 and 3
Exit: export work, overlap month, staff retraining
Three-year total

Two sums worth doing. If your first-year Birdeye fee is B and an 8% fee applies at two annual renewals, three years cost B x 3.16 if each renewal adds 8% to the original fee (1 + 1.08 + 1.08), or B x 3.2464 if it compounds (1 + 1.08 + 1.1664). The terms do not say which, so ask. On Reputation, 40 locations on the $115 plan is 40 x 115 x 12, or $55,200 a year before add-ons. Messaging is separate on most platforms, and WhatsApp is priced by Meta per delivered message, varying by message category and the recipient's country code. India and Brazil have their own rates. Parts of Europe are grouped into regional rates.

When you should stay with them

Stay, or choose them, if most of these are true:

  • You run many locations and listings accuracy drives footfall. Birdeye and Reputation both sell listings as a core product. Relay's documentation does not cover listings management.
  • Review generation is your main goal. Both offer review requests, and Relay's public material centres on answering and routing.
  • Your support desk works well, and reviews rarely contain cases that need one.
  • You are mid-term with more than a year left. Payments may be non-cancellable, so finish the term and use the time to prepare.
  • You have a single location and a small review volume. You may need neither, and a manual process can do the job.

Consider moving if the same complaint keeps arriving in reviews and support with no link between them, or if people across teams re-key cases by hand.

The rules that apply to any tool

Software that sends review requests can put you in breach if it is set up badly. This is general information. Rules depend on your facts and market, so check your own.

The near-universal principle: reviews must be genuine, and you shouldn't filter out the unhappy ones. Google's policy bars incentives for reviews and says businesses must not "discourage or prohibit negative reviews, or selectively solicit positive reviews from customers".

MarketWhat to know
USThe FTC rule took effect on 21 October 2024. Incentives may not require or imply a positive or negative review. 16 CFR 465 has the text
UKCMA guidance warns against suppressing genuine reviews or selectively promoting them. The CMA said in October 2026 that fake reviews remain a focus
AustraliaThe ACCC says businesses may mislead consumers if they remove genuine negative reviews, and lists penalties from past cases
EU, IndiaWe could not open a primary source on review rules for this post. Check Directive 2019/2161 in the EU and your consumer regulator in India

Ask every vendor to show how review requests are sent. If the flow only sends happy customers to Google, turn that off.

Questions for the sales call

  1. What is the three-year total in writing, for my real locations, including every add-on used in this meeting?
  2. What notice is needed to leave, and will you remind me? Can the notice period be 30 days on my order form?
  3. Is there a renewal uplift, and can it be capped or removed?
  4. Which of my countries are fully supported for text requests, reporting and inbox?
  5. Where is my data hosted, and can I choose the region?
  6. Show a one star review becoming a task for my delivery team, and the outcome coming back.
  7. Which AI replies can go out without approval, and where do I switch that off?
  8. What can I export on the last day, in what format, and for how long after?

Moving without losing history

  • Export before you give notice. Birdeye's help article describes a Download Reviews (Excel) option from the Reviews tab. Test it on a full date range.
  • Check the terms for the exit window. We did not find a post-termination export period in Birdeye's terms, so get one written into the order form.
  • Reviews stay on the platforms. Your Google reviews and replies live on Google, so you lose reporting history when you switch, and the public record survives. Keep the export for trend lines.
  • Reconnect each profile. List every Google, Facebook and marketplace profile and who holds admin access.
  • Re-create what the old tool held. Reply templates, review-request timing, opt-outs and location groupings need moving by hand. Carry over opt-outs first.
  • Check hosting. If customer data moves between countries, read the local rule. The European Commission and Australia's OAIC both publish guidance on transfers.

Who owns what during a switch

SituationOwnerDo firstNever
Renewal date inside 120 daysFinanceFind the order form, confirm notice dateAssume the standard terms apply
Vendor offers a discount to stayBudget holderAsk for the three-year total and uplift capSign in the same call
One star review arrives mid-switchSupport leadReply on the platform directlyLeave it until the new tool is live
Review request flow filters by scoreLegal or complianceTurn the filter off and record itKeep it because reviews look better
Export is missing dataProject ownerAsk the vendor in writing, list what is missingGive notice before you have the files

Messages you can copy

Names, dates and numbers in these messages are placeholders.

Quote request:

We have 14 locations in the UK, Malaysia and the UAE. Please send a written three-year total including every add-on shown in our call, renewal uplift, notice period and messaging charges. We will compare on that figure.

Non-renewal notice:

Under section 2.3 of your terms, this is written notice that we will not renew order form 4471, which ends on 30 June 2027. Please confirm receipt and the last date we can export our data.

Chaser when nothing has come back:

I sent our non-renewal notice on 12 March and have no confirmation yet. Please confirm receipt by Friday. I have attached the original.

Closing the account:

Our export is complete and checked. Please confirm the account closes on 30 June, that no further invoices will be raised, and when our data will be deleted.

Public reply during a changeover:

Priya, a replacement should have reached you last week and it did not. Sorry. Ana in our Pune team will call you today on the number on your order and tell you the delivery date.

The hard case, when a vendor will not give you what you asked for:

I understand the fee is standard. We still need a written cap before signing. If that is not possible, tell me this week so we can plan the exit before the notice date.

A plan for Monday

Timings are a suggested starting point, not a benchmark.

  1. Day 1: Find the order form. Write down the term end, notice date and uplift.
  2. Week 1: Fill in the worksheet with last year's real spend.
  3. Week 2: Pull 50 recent reviews. Mark how many needed another team, and how many got that help.
  4. Week 3: Take a full export and open it.
  5. Week 4: Run two vendor calls using the questions above.
  6. At least 120 days before the notice date: Decide.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Comparing year one prices and ignoring renewals.
  • Reading the standard terms and forgetting the order form overrides them.
  • Buying for today's location count when the expansion is signed.
  • Giving notice before testing the export.
  • Letting a tool send requests only to happy customers.
  • Assuming a US-built feature works in your country.

What to measure

Track these before and after any change, using your own baseline.

  • Share of reviews answered, by platform and location.
  • Time to first reply on one and two star reviews.
  • Share of negative reviews that became a case with an owner.
  • Repeat complaints on the same theme, month on month.
  • Three-year cost per location against your worksheet.

If replies rise and repeat complaints stay flat, you bought faster replies and nothing else. Google's reply process can also delay posting, since replies usually take up to 10 minutes to review and sometimes up to 30 days, so measure send time separately from publish time.

What runs in Relay today

Relay brings reviews, public posts, email and messaging into one queue as tickets with owners, SLA clocks and an event log. Replies are drafted for a person to approve, and a person stays on every refund. Alerts explain which theme moved and why.

Limits. Replies on each channel need that channel's connection set up first. App Store and Play Store replies still go through the developer console. Listings management isn't documented in Relay, and neither is importing history from another tool, so ask us what is possible for your data. It can run in your own cloud. Each division can be bought alone and plans are quoted on a call. Contact us if you want to compare it with your worksheet.

For related reading, see how to answer every Google review and the software buyer's guide.

Common questions

Does Birdeye publish its prices?

As of November 2026 its pricing page is a form that asks for your details and location count, and it shows no price. Ask for a written three-year figure. Include every add-on you saw in the sales call.

How much notice does Birdeye need to stop a renewal?

Its terms, effective 13 May 2026, say at least 90 days' written notice before the renewal date unless your order form says otherwise. Read your order form, since it takes priority. Then diarise the date.

Is Reputation cheaper than Birdeye?

We can't say, because Birdeye does not publish a price. Reputation lists $80 to $150 per location per month as of November 2026, with some features sold as add-ons. Compare on the three-year worksheet using written quotes.

Can I take my reviews with me?

The reviews stay on Google and the other platforms, and you can reconnect those profiles to a new tool. What you can lose is the reporting history held inside the old tool. Export it before you give notice and check that the file is complete.

Should I leave Birdeye mid-contract?

Usually not, because order form payments can be non-cancellable. Use the remaining term to test alternatives and export data. Decide well before the notice date.

Sources

See what Relay can do for your customer service

Get a personalised 30 minute demo on your own channels and policies. We show you Relay handling your real conversations, then set it up with you.

  • Built and connected for you
  • Can run in your own cloud
  • A person on every refund

Brands we work with

  • Bolt
  • Dave & Buster's
  • ETV Win
  • Malachite Cars
  • Space Angel
  • Infinity Quest
Made by Thinkiyo© 2026 Thinkiyo. Relay is a Thinkiyo product.Examples use Lumen Parcel, a fictional brand.