Insights/Ecommerce

How to handle wrong size exchange requests on Instagram DMs

Change of mind or your mistake? How return rights differ by market, a triage table, DM replies you can paste and a checklist for your team.

Thinkiyo team··11 min read

First work out whose mistake it is. If you shipped the wrong size, or your listing or size chart was wrong, treat it as your error, and pay for the swap. If the customer chose a size that didn't fit, your return policy applies, along with any statutory cancellation right for online orders where you sell. Then answer in the DM with the options you can actually give, move address and phone details out of public comments, and keep one case open until the new size is on its way.

What the rules say

Two different rules get mixed up here. The principle that holds almost everywhere is that goods must match what you sold, so a wrong item or a misdescribed size is a seller problem. A simple change of mind is different. Some markets give online buyers a right to cancel and others leave it to your policy. Where you do have a return policy, you are generally held to it. Check your own market. This is general information, not legal advice.

MarketCustomer picked the wrong sizeYou sent the wrong size or the listing was wrong
USThe FTC's Cooling-Off Rule excludes sales made entirely online. Your policy and state law govern.Check state law and your terms. Treat as a seller error and cover the swap.
UKCancel within 14 days of receipt, then another 14 days to return. Customer pays direct return costs if you told them that. You refund the standard delivery and may deduct for handling beyond what a shop would allow.Trader's responsibility, including postage for repair or replacement. The short-term right to reject lasts 30 days.
EU14 days from delivery without giving a reason. Customer pays return postage unless you offer to or failed to tell them.Trader covers the return of defective goods.
AustraliaNo entitlement to a remedy for change of mind. If you have a change-of-mind policy, you must follow it.Goods very different from their description can be a major failure. Customer chooses refund or replacement, and you reimburse reasonable return costs.
IndiaYour return, refund and exchange terms apply and must be disclosed, with amended disclosure rules from 1 January 2027.Sellers and inventory platforms cannot refuse return or refund if goods are not as advertised or agreed (rules 6(3) and 7(4)).
Canada (Ontario)Cooling-off rights cover door-to-door sales, gyms and similar, and that page doesn't list ordinary online orders. Check your province.Check provincial law. Treat as seller error.
SingaporePart 3 of the Act applies to goods that do not conform to the contract, so a fit preference alone falls under your policy.Non-conforming goods give a right to repair or replacement at the seller's cost within a reasonable time.

One recent EU change affects this workflow. Directive 2023/2673 requires an online withdrawal function for contracts that carry a withdrawal right. A May 2026 summary from law firm Greenberg Traurig describes it as applying from 19 June 2026 in Germany, with a labelled button and a confirmation on a durable medium such as email. Check how your member state implemented it, and make sure a request made through that function reaches the team answering DMs.

Size is often your data problem

Treat a cluster of wrong size requests as a product issue before you treat them as a support issue. One style that runs small, one size chart in centimetres on one page and inches on another, or one model photo that misleads about fit will generate these requests every week. If the size chart was wrong, the case moves from the second column of that table to the third.

Instagram gives you less time than you think

Meta's messaging policy gives businesses a standard window to respond to a user's message. It lasts 24 hours for most user actions and may last up to 7 days from a first message sent after clicking a Click-to-Direct ad. The same policy describes a Human Agent tag for manual replies in a separate 7-day period, and warns that using tags outside approved cases may bring restrictions on sending messages. So a request that comes in on Friday night needs a plan. Check Meta's current documentation for the tags you can use on your account, and don't plan around a window you haven't confirmed.

Comments are public and permanent. Never ask for an address, phone number or order details in one.

Triage table

SituationOwnerFirst moveNever
Inside return window, customer chose wrong sizeAgentOffer the exchange or refund your policy allowsAdd a fee your policy doesn't state
You shipped the wrong sizeAgent, warehouse leadApologise once, send the right size, cover returnCharge return postage
Size chart or listing was wrongAgent, merchandisingTreat as seller error, fix the listingBlame the customer's measurements
Outside window, change of mindSenior agentExplain the policy, offer a discretionary exception if allowedPretend the window is a legal limit if it isn't
Worn or tags removedSenior agentCheck the policy against the reason for returnRefuse a faulty item because it was worn
Size out of stockAgentOffer a refund, a waitlist, or a similar styleIssue credit as the only option where the law gives a refund
Final sale itemSenior agentCheck whether it's faulty or not as describedSay no refunds on sale items, full stop
Public comment asking for an updateSocial ownerShort reply, point to the DMAsk for details in the comment
Second exchange on one orderSenior agentOffer a refund or a fit consultationKeep exchanging the same item blindly

The ACCC has flagged blanket statements such as "Sale items cannot be returned, exchanged or refunded" as potentially misleading, because they ignore rights that apply when goods are faulty. Check your own final sale wording.

Replies you can paste

First reply, inside the window

Hi [name], that dress runs close to size, so this comes up. Your order is inside our [X]-day window. I can swap it for the [size] or refund you, whichever you prefer. If you want to swap, I'll send the pickup steps here.

Public reply

Hi [name], just replied in your DMs so we can sort this without your details going on here.

Update when there is no news

Hi [name], the [size] is due back in stock on [date]. Nothing's moved yet, and I'll message you here that day. If you'd rather not wait, I can refund you today.

Closing reply

Your [size] is on its way, tracking [link]. If it doesn't fit, message me here and I'll sort it, you won't need to start over.

Hard case: outside the return window

Hi [name], your order was delivered on [date], so it's past our [X]-day window for size changes. I can't do a standard exchange. I've asked [name] on our team whether we can make an exception, and you'll have an answer by [day]. If the item is faulty or isn't as described, tell me, because that's handled differently.

Hard case: you shipped the wrong one

Hi [name], that's our mistake, you ordered a [size] and we sent a [size]. I'm sending the right one today. You don't pay anything for the return, and I'll send a label here.

A Monday checklist

Time targets are suggested starting points only. They are not benchmarks.

  1. Separate your wrong size tag from your wrong item sent tag, and split out size chart wrong as well.
  2. Read your return policy against the market table above. List each country you ship to and the rule for each.
  3. Remove blanket statements on sale items unless you've checked them with local advice.
  4. Publish one size chart format across every listing.
  5. Write a rule for who pays return postage in each scenario.
  6. Suggested Instagram first reply: within 4 hours while you're open, and before the end of the same day. Check your 24-hour window.
  7. Staff a weekend check, or write the message that goes out on Monday when a window has closed.
  8. Define what happens to a public comment: reply once, point to DMs, link it to the case.
  9. Each week, pull the top 5 styles by wrong size contacts and send them to merchandising.

Mistakes people make

  • Calling everything change of mind, including the orders you picked wrong.
  • Asking for an address in a comment reply.
  • Charging return postage on an error that was yours.
  • Keeping one case in DMs and a separate one for the comment, so two agents give two answers.
  • Citing a 7-day policy to a UK or EU customer as if it replaced the 14-day cancellation right. Your policy can be more generous than the statute. It can't take rights away.
  • Saying no on a final sale item without asking why it's coming back.
  • Letting a Friday DM sit until Monday and then discovering the window has shut.
  • Sending a new size without checking stock, then having to apologise twice.

What to measure

  • Wrong size contacts per 100 orders, by style. The number merchandising can act on.
  • Share of exchanges caused by your error. Picking, listing and size chart mistakes.
  • Time from DM to exchange shipped.
  • DM response inside the 24-hour window. A hard operational floor on Instagram.
  • Second exchanges on one order. Rising means your fit advice isn't helping.
  • Return postage cost by reason. Shows whether a size guide fix would pay for itself.

It's working when the top styles on the wrong size list change after you fix them, and no customer has to ask twice.

Worked example

This is an example scenario. The store, customer, order and messages are made up to show how Relay works. It is not a customer story.

Valentina Ruiz writes to fashion store Threadline in an Instagram DM, in Spanish: Hola, me llegó el vestido pero es una talla más pequeña. ¿Puedo cambiarlo por una M? (Hi, the dress arrived but it is one size too small. Can I exchange it for a medium?) Later that day she comments on the store's latest post: Sigo esperando respuesta sobre mi cambio. (Still waiting for an answer about my exchange.)

Relay tags the message as a return request for wrong size and matches the public comment to the same case, so the team doesn't answer twice. Threadline's policy allows exchanges within 15 days of delivery for unworn items with tags on. The agent checks the delivery date in the store, starts from the drafted exchange template, and sends both options in Spanish:

Hola Valentina, sentimos que la talla no sea la correcta. Podemos cambiarlo por una M o hacerte el reembolso, como prefieras. Te enviamos los pasos para la recogida por aquí. (Hi Valentina, sorry the size is not right. We can exchange it for a medium or refund you, whichever you prefer. We will send the pickup steps here.)

The agent posts a short reply in Spanish under the comment, pointing to DMs. Her address, phone number and pickup time stay in the private chat. Outside the window, the case is routed to a person who can make an exception. The case stays open with an SLA clock until the new size is on its way, and any new message joins it.

See also damaged on arrival complaints and how to answer every Google review.

What runs in Relay today

One queue, tagging, matching a public comment to the DM case, routing, SLA clocks, reporting and drafted replies a person approves run in Relay today. Drafts start from a template for the request category, so your agent adds your policy detail and handles the language. Instagram comments and DMs are among the channels you can connect. Refunds are a human-only topic.

These parts are on the way: order lookups from your store, exchange and refund actions inside your limits, and pickup booking with your courier. Until then, an agent checks the order in your store, approves the draft and books the pickup in your own system. If exchange requests pile up in your DMs, contact us.

Common questions

Do I have to accept a return if the customer ordered the wrong size?

It depends on the market. Online buyers in the UK and EU generally have 14 days to cancel. In Australia a change of mind gives no entitlement, though your own policy binds you if you have one.

Who pays return postage on a wrong size return?

It depends on whose error it was. Under UK and EU distance selling rules the customer generally pays for a change-of-mind return, provided you told them so, and if you shipped the wrong item the cost is yours. Spell it out in your policy.

Can I refuse an exchange if the tags are off?

Your policy can set conditions for a change-of-mind return, and in the UK you may deduct for handling beyond what a shop would allow. Those conditions do not defeat a claim that the item was faulty or not as described. Ask the reason before you decline.

Can I message a customer on Instagram after 24 hours?

Meta's messaging policy sets a standard window of 24 hours for most user actions, or up to 7 days after a first message from a Click-to-Direct ad, and describes a Human Agent tag for manual replies within 7 days. Tag availability depends on your setup and Meta's current rules. Check before relying on it.

Sources

See what Relay can do for your customer service

Get a personalised 30 minute demo on your own channels and policies. We show you Relay handling your real conversations, then set it up with you.

  • Built and connected for you
  • Can run in your own cloud
  • A person on every refund

Brands we work with

  • Bolt
  • Dave & Buster's
  • ETV Win
  • Malachite Cars
  • Space Angel
  • Infinity Quest
Made by Thinkiyo© 2026 Thinkiyo. Relay is a Thinkiyo product.Examples use Lumen Parcel, a fictional brand.