Insights/Ecommerce

How to handle damaged on arrival complaints without the back and forth

Who carries transit damage by market, what proof you can ask for, a triage table and replies you can paste. Settle it in one exchange.

Thinkiyo team··11 min read

Treat a parcel that arrives broken as your problem first and the courier's problem second. In one reply, ask for the single thing you still need, say what happens next, and start the replacement or refund without waiting on a carrier claim. Most of the back and forth comes from asking for proof in instalments and from telling the customer to chase the courier, which in many markets you cannot do.

What the rules say

The principle that holds in most markets: the seller answers to the customer for goods that reach them damaged, and any dispute with the courier sits between the seller and the courier. The notable exceptions are in the table below. Check your own market and your own terms, because the detail varies and some countries regulate by state or province. This is general information, not legal advice.

MarketWho carries transit damageWorth knowing
USDepends on the contract. Under the Uniform Commercial Code, a contract that only requires shipment moves risk to the buyer at handover to the carrier. One that requires delivery to a destination moves it when the goods are tendered there.Your terms decide much of this, and state versions apply. Many stores replace anyway because arguing costs more than the item.
UKThe trader, until the customer or someone they named has possession.Exception: a carrier the customer arranged, which you did not offer as an option. The short-term right to reject runs 30 days.
EUThe trader, from dispatch until the customer receives the goods.Customers can ask for repair or replacement, then a price reduction or refund if neither is possible.
AustraliaThe seller. Consumer Affairs Victoria says the store is responsible for resolving issues with the courier.The remedy depends on whether the failure is major or minor. For a major failure the customer chooses refund or replacement.
IndiaSellers and inventory platforms cannot refuse to take back or refund goods that are defective or not as advertised (rules 6(3) and 7(4)).Grievance officers must acknowledge within 48 hours and resolve within one month. From 1 January 2027 they must also give the complainant a copy of the complaint as recorded.
SingaporeGoods must conform at delivery. Non-conformity showing within 6 months is presumed to have existed then.Repair or replacement must happen within a reasonable time, at the seller's cost.
UAEFailing to repair or replace a defective product free of charge is punishable.The law covers suppliers across the UAE mainland and free zones and goods sold through UAE-registered ecommerce platforms. It does not apply to ecommerce between UAE customers and businesses registered outside the UAE.

The Australian guidance has the clearest example. A customer finds a broken door handle on a new fridge and the store says it must have happened in transit. The regulators' industry guide answers that the store still had an obligation to supply goods of acceptable quality.

Watch your policy wording too. In a February 2025 sweep, the ACCC flagged time limits for returning faulty goods, including a clause asking customers to report damage within 30 days of delivery. It also flagged keeping delivery fees on faulty items and charging restocking fees on them.

What proof you can ask for

Ask for what you need to make the decision and for nothing else. A useful default is one photo of the item, one of the outer box and the shipping label if it is still there, and the order number.

Proof of purchase is a fair request. Original packaging is a weaker one. The ACCC says a faulty product does not need to be in its original packaging, so a customer who threw the box away may still be owed a remedy.

There is a practical reason to ask them to keep the packaging for now: your carrier claim may depend on it. Australia Post, as one example, says a damage report needs the item and packaging presented, that compensation for domestic damage generally goes to the recipient unless a waiver is given, and that items not adequately packed are not eligible. Read your own carrier's terms before you write your macro. Treat the carrier claim as your cost recovery. It should not delay the customer's remedy.

Triage table

SituationOwnerFirst moveNever
Damaged, photos complete, in stockAgent, then replacement approverApprove and ship the replacementAsk for a second round of photos out of habit
Photo of item, no photo of boxAgentAsk once for the box, and say what happens afterHold the remedy if the box is gone and the damage is clear
Out of stockAgent, then approverOffer a refund or a named alternativeIssue store credit as the only option
Unsafe: broken glass, leaking battery, exposed wiringSenior agent, product safetyTell them to stop using it and not to post it back until you confirm howAsk them to pack it up and drop it off
Large itemLogistics leadBook collection at your costAsk the customer to arrange a return
Customer booked their own courierSenior agentCheck your terms and local ruleAssume they carry the loss everywhere
Marketplace orderMarketplace opsFollow that marketplace's process and record the caseSend the customer to the platform without checking who owes the remedy
Third claim from one address this quarterRisk leadReview history privately, and decide on a person's sign-offAccuse anyone in writing
Public post or reviewSocial ownerShort public reply, move details privatePost order numbers, addresses or photos of their home

Replies you can paste

First reply, proof incomplete

Hi [name], I'm sorry the [item] arrived broken. I can see order [number]. Please send one photo of the outer box on this thread and keep the packaging for now. Once I have that, I'll send a replacement. If you'd rather have your money back, just say so.

Public reply

Sorry about this, [name]. That shouldn't have arrived in that state. We've sent you a direct message so we can sort it without your order details going on here.

Update when there is no news

Hi [name], your replacement hasn't shipped yet because the [item] is due back in our warehouse on [date]. I'll write again on [date] with tracking, or sooner if it moves. If you don't want to wait, I can refund you today.

Closing reply

Your replacement is on its way, tracking [link]. You can recycle the broken one now, we don't need it back. If this one has a problem, reply here and it comes straight back to me.

Hard case: the damage looks like wear or misuse

Hi [name], thanks for the photos. The [part] looks worn rather than broken in transit, and it's been [X] months since delivery. I can't treat this as delivery damage. I've asked [name], our senior agent, to look at whether it's a product fault, and she'll reply by [day]. If there is a fault, you may still be covered and we'll tell you how.

Hard case: you can't replace it

Hi [name], that [item] is discontinued, so I can't send another. I can refund the full [amount], including delivery, to your original card today. Or I can send [alternative] at no extra cost. Which would you prefer?

A Monday checklist

Time targets below are suggested starting points. They are not benchmarks. Set your own from your volumes and your local rules.

  1. Write one damage macro that asks for everything at once. Remove every other version.
  2. Decide who can approve a replacement and up to what value. Write the limit down.
  3. Set a rule: the customer's remedy does not wait for the carrier claim.
  4. Remove report-within-X-days language from your faulty goods policy unless a lawyer in your market has cleared it.
  5. Add a do-not-return rule for items cheaper to replace than to ship back.
  6. Suggested first reply: within 4 working hours. Suggested decision: within 1 working day of complete proof.
  7. Tag every case by SKU, courier, warehouse and damage type.
  8. Once a week, have one person review the top damage pattern and act on it.
  9. Put a safety path on one page and teach it to every agent.

Mistakes people make

  • Asking for proof in instalments. Photo of item, then photo of box, then label, then a video.
  • Telling the customer to claim from the courier. In the UK, EU and Australia the seller generally has that job.
  • Requiring the original box as a condition of any remedy.
  • Asking for a return on a $12 item that costs $9 to send back and arrives more broken.
  • Refunding the item and keeping the delivery fee. The ACCC has flagged this practice for faulty goods.
  • Sending a replacement in the same packaging that failed.
  • Replying in English to a complaint written in another language, then wondering why the customer needs a second explanation.

What to measure

  • Messages per damage case. The best single test of this process. It should fall towards two or three.
  • Time from complete proof to remedy issued. Track median and the slowest tenth.
  • Share of first replies that asked for everything missing. Sample 20 a week by hand.
  • Damage rate by SKU, courier and warehouse. This is where the money is. Replying well does not reduce breakage.
  • Reopen rate on damage cases. Rising means replacements are also arriving damaged.
  • Carrier recovery. Claims lodged and value recovered, so the finance team can see the trade-off.

You'll know it's working when a damage case usually closes in one exchange and the top SKU on your damage list changes after a packaging fix.

Worked example

This is an example scenario. The store, customer, order and messages are made up to show how Relay works. It is not a customer story.

Mei Chen emails a home goods store, Threadline, in Mandarin with one photo: 我的订单60418今天到了,但是花瓶碎了。我发了照片。我想要一个新的。 (My order 60418 arrived today, but the vase is broken. I am sending a photo. I want a new one.)

The photo shows the cracked vase on a table and not the box. Threadline's policy asks for a photo of the item and a photo of the outer box. Relay tags the email as damaged on arrival and puts it in the queue with a drafted reply from the damage template. The agent, who reads Mandarin, checks the policy, adds the one missing thing and approves:

陈女士,给您带来不便,非常抱歉。请在这封邮件里发一张包装盒的照片,我们好给您寄一个新花瓶。 (Ms Chen, sorry for the trouble. Please send a photo of the box on this email, so we can send a new vase.)

When the second photo arrives, the case is routed to the replacements team, and a person approves or declines. The agent sends the update in Mandarin. If the case waits too long, the SLA clock moves it up the escalation ladder. When several customers report broken vases in the same week, the theme shows up as one group, and the team can look at packaging or the courier.

For related cases, see late delivery refund requests and wrong size exchanges.

What runs in Relay today

One queue, tagging, routing to the replacements team, SLA clocks, the escalation ladder, theme grouping, the event log and drafted replies a person approves run in Relay today. Drafts start from a template for the complaint category, so your agent adds your policy detail and handles the language. Refunds and replacements are human-only topics. If damage complaints spike, alerts go in-app and to Slack, webhook or email.

These parts are on the way: order lookups from your store, replacement and refund actions inside limits you set, and Shopify and Salesforce connections. Until then, the person who approves the case creates the replacement in your own store. If damage claims are taking three emails to settle, contact us.

Common questions

Can I refuse a damage claim if the customer threw away the box?

Often not, and it depends on your market. The ACCC says a faulty product does not need to be in its original packaging. Ask for other evidence such as a photo of the item and the delivery date, and treat the box as useful for your carrier claim only.

Can I tell the customer to claim from the courier?

In the UK, EU and Australia, the seller generally deals with the courier, with limited exceptions. In the US the answer depends on your terms and the shipment arrangement. Check your own market before you write this into a macro.

Does the customer have to send the broken item back?

Only if you need it, and in many cases you won't. Where you do want it back, faulty goods returns are generally at the seller's cost in markets such as the UK and Australia. For low-value items, write off the return and save the postage.

What if I suspect a false damage claim?

Review the history privately and make a named person responsible for the decision. Ask for specific evidence, and never put an accusation in writing. A pattern across addresses or accounts is stronger evidence than one odd photo.

How fast do I have to respond?

Many consumer laws say a reasonable time rather than a number of hours. India is one exception for platforms, with 48 hours to acknowledge and one month to resolve a grievance. Set your own internal target and publish it to your team.

Sources

See what Relay can do for your customer service

Get a personalised 30 minute demo on your own channels and policies. We show you Relay handling your real conversations, then set it up with you.

  • Built and connected for you
  • Can run in your own cloud
  • A person on every refund

Brands we work with

  • Bolt
  • Dave & Buster's
  • ETV Win
  • Malachite Cars
  • Space Angel
  • Infinity Quest
Made by Thinkiyo© 2026 Thinkiyo. Relay is a Thinkiyo product.Examples use Lumen Parcel, a fictional brand.