Insights/Automotive

How a car brand can handle service delay complaints at dealers

Repair delay rules by market, who owns the case between dealer and brand, replies to copy, and what to measure across a dealer network.

Thinkiyo team··11 min read

Give the customer a named person, a reason and a date for the next update on the same day they complain. Then find out what is actually holding the car: parts, manufacturer approval, or a booking backlog. Waiting for parts is a reason, and it may not be an excuse. Australia's regulator says a repair delayed by unavailable parts can still count as a failure to fix within a reasonable time, which can turn a small fault into a claim for a refund or replacement.

What the law expects

Nearly everywhere, repairs under a guarantee or a paid service must be done within a reasonable time, with the meaning of "reasonable" set by the facts. Few of the markets we checked give a fixed number of days. Check your own market and state, and whether the job is a warranty repair, a consumer law claim or a paid service, since different rules can apply to each.

This is general information, not legal advice. Outcomes depend on the fault, the vehicle's age, the contract and local law.

MarketRule
AustraliaRepairs must be free and within a reasonable time. If a minor failure is not fixed in time, the buyer can get it done elsewhere and recover the cost, or treat it as major. The ACCC's guide for dealers says this applies even if the delay is due to unavailable parts.
UKWhere a services contract fixes no time, the trader must perform within a reasonable time. What is reasonable is a question of fact.
EUFaulty goods must be repaired or replaced free of charge. If that cannot be done within a reasonable time and without significant inconvenience, the buyer can ask for a full or partial refund.
US (California)No federal day count that we could confirm. California's lemon law presumes a reasonable number of repair attempts within 18 months or 18,000 miles, whichever comes first, after four or more attempts at the same problem, two attempts on a safety defect, or more than 30 days in the shop, not necessarily in a row. Other states have their own rules.
SingaporeThe Lemon Law FAQ says sellers must repair or replace within a reasonable time without significant inconvenience, or the buyer can seek a price reduction or refund. Defects found within six months are presumed to have been there at delivery.
IndiaRemoval of defects, replacement, refund and compensation can be ordered by consumer commissions. Complaints must be filed within two years of the cause of action.

What the Australian guidance adds

Australia publishes unusually specific guidance, which is useful even if you operate elsewhere because it shows how a regulator reasons about delays. All of it comes from the ACCC's industry guide, published in 2018, unless linked otherwise.

  • Reasonable time is judged as if parts were available. The test looks at the nature of the problem and how hard it is to find. A fault first judged minor can become major if parts later become unavailable.
  • Five weeks has come up in the guide's examples. The guide gives one case of an engine fault not fixed within five weeks, and another of a noise fault where repairs kept the car away for a combined five weeks, as likely major failures. Treat those as illustrations and not a limit.
  • Waiting for the manufacturer does not excuse the dealer. Pre-approval for a warranty repair should not be delayed unreasonably. The buyer can go elsewhere, or seek a refund or replacement if the delay is major.
  • The dealer cannot point at the manufacturer. The ACCC says buyers should go to the dealer first, and the dealer must not direct them to the manufacturer for a remedy. Manufacturers must supply parts and repair facilities for a reasonable time.
  • A warranty does not cap the rights. Manufacturer and extended warranties sit alongside the automatic guarantees.

Enforcement is real. Mazda Australia was ordered to pay AUD 11.5 million in 2024 after telling nine customers the only remedy was a repair, even after multiple failed attempts. One vehicle had three engine replacements.

The rules are also moving. Australian consumer ministers agreed in November 2025 to add civil penalties and expanded enforcement powers for the consumer guarantee and supplier indemnification regime. As of Treasury's December 2025 page, draft laws were still to come, and we could not confirm a later stage. Check before you rely on this.

Dealer or brand: who owns what

Customers complain to the brand because the badge is on the car. The dealer has the car and the facts. Both need a job.

SituationWho owns itFirst stepNever
Car in workshop, no update for daysDealer service managerCall with status and next update dateSend the customer to the manufacturer
Waiting on a partDealer, with brand parts teamConfirm order and expected dateSay "parts are out of our hands" and stop
Waiting on warranty approvalBrand warranty teamDecide, and tell the dealer the same dayLeave the dealer guessing
Repeat repair, same faultBrand escalation deskReview the history and remedy optionsSay a repair is the only option by reflex
Asks for a loan carDealer service managerCheck policy, answer oncePromise one the dealer cannot provide
Asks for refund or replacementSenior person, legal if neededReview fault, repair history, local ruleRefuse on the phone
Safety concernBrand safety or technical teamEscalate now, advise on drivingTell them to keep driving to save the booking
Public postBrand social teamReply, route to dealer, move privateDiscuss the fault publicly

Replies to copy

First reply, private

Hi [name], your [model] has been with [dealer] since [date] and nobody has given you a proper update. That is on us. I have asked [dealer contact] for the current status, what it is waiting on and when it should be ready. You will hear from me by [time, date]. Your reference is [number], and I am your contact until the car is back with you.

Public reply

[Name], your car should not have sat for two weeks without an update. We have passed this to the service manager at [dealer]. Please DM your registration and we will take it from there in private.

Update when there is no news

Hi [name], there is still no change on your [model]. It is waiting on [part or approval], last confirmed [date]. I will check again on [date] and write to you then. If this is causing you real trouble, tell me and I will see what we can do about transport.

Closing reply

Hi [name], your [model] is ready at [dealer]. The work done was [summary], and it is [covered or not]. If the same fault comes back, send me a note on this thread and it will go straight to me.

The hard case: the fault is minor and they want a refund

Hi [name], I understand why you want out after this. I have read the workshop report. The fault is [description] and the dealer says it can be fixed by [date], so right now we are offering a repair at no cost. If it is not fixed by then, or the fault comes back, tell me and we will look at this again, including a refund or replacement where the law allows. If you disagree you can raise this with [regulator or consumer body].

Before you send this, have someone senior check the repair history. Repeated faults may change the answer. Australia's guidance says multiple minor failures can together amount to a major failure.

A timeline to adopt on Monday

Time targets below are a suggested starting point, not a benchmark. The brand should set them.

  • At drop-off. Dealer gives a date for the first update, and writes it on the job.
  • Every three working days while in the workshop. One update, even if nothing has changed.
  • On a parts delay. Dealer tells the brand, the customer hears within one working day.
  • Warranty approval requests. Brand answers within two working days.
  • Complaint received. Named owner within one working day.
  • Dealer misses the deadline. Reminder, then brand escalation desk, then regional service manager, then senior team.
  • At the three-week mark, or sooner for an undrivable car. Someone senior reviews options, including transport and remedies.

Have a written answer on loan cars. Your policy, and your market, will decide whether you offer one. Staff should not be making it up at the counter.

Mistakes teams make

  • Telling the customer to contact the manufacturer. In Australia the regulator says the dealer must not do that.
  • Treating "parts are on back order" as a complete answer.
  • Letting warranty approval sit, then blaming the dealer. The customer does not care which of you is slow, and in Australia the manufacturer's delay does not excuse the dealer.
  • Saying a repair is the only remedy without checking the history. That is what cost Mazda.
  • Counting only the current visit. Days in the shop add up, and California's test need not be consecutive.
  • Replying in public with a registration number or the fault detail.
  • Closing the case when the car is collected. The test is whether the fault stays fixed.

What to measure

  • Time from complaint to named owner, by dealer.
  • Days in the workshop, by fault type and dealer.
  • Share of open jobs with an update in the last three working days.
  • Warranty approval time.
  • Repeat repair rate for the same fault.
  • Reopen rate by dealer.

You know it is working when the worst dealer's numbers improve and the brand's escalation desk gets fewer cases about silence.

A worked example

This is an example scenario. The brand, dealer, people and messages are made up to show how Relay works. It is not a customer story.

Nikos Papadopoulos posts on X in Greek about a dealer in Stuttgart: "Το αυτοκίνητό μου είναι στο σέρβις εδώ και δύο εβδομάδες και κανείς δεν με ενημερώνει. Στουτγάρδη. @orbitmotors" (My car has been at the service centre for two weeks and nobody gives an update. Stuttgart.)

Relay tags the post as a service delay, matches it to a case and routes it to the dealer for that city, using Orbit's dealer list.

The case goes to the Stuttgart dealer's queue with a first response deadline the brand team set, plus the post, the customer's history and a short summary. Relay drafts a short public reply from the template, and an agent puts it in Greek and approves it: "Νίκο, συγγνώμη. Η υπόθεσή σας στάλθηκε στον αντιπρόσωπο στη Στουτγάρδη. Παρακαλώ στείλτε μας τα στοιχεία σε DM." (Sorry, Nikos. Your case has gone to the Stuttgart dealer. Please send the details by DM.) The agent checks that no phone number or registration appears in public.

If the dealer does not respond in time, the ladder takes over: a reminder, the brand's escalation desk, the regional service manager, then critical. Each step is recorded in the event log. The brand can see response times and reopen rates.

What runs in Relay today

All of this runs in Relay today: one queue, tagging, matching a public post to a case, routing to dealers, SLA clocks, the four step escalation ladder and drafted replies a person approves. Drafts start from category templates, so agents check them against your policy before sending.

If your dealer network handles complaints like this, contact us. For the sales side, read how to answer customers when a car delivery date is missed. Long repair stories often end up in reviews, so see how to answer every Google review without a bigger team.

Common questions

How long is too long for a car repair?

Most laws say a reasonable time and give no number. The ACCC's guide uses five week examples as likely major failures, and California uses more than 30 days in the shop as one test in its lemon law. Treat neither as a limit for your market.

Does a parts shortage excuse the delay?

It may not. The ACCC says a failure not fixed within a reasonable time can be treated as major even if the delay is due to unavailable parts. Other markets assess this on the facts, so tell the customer the real reason and keep the updates coming.

Can a dealer send a customer to the manufacturer?

In Australia, no, the dealer must help and must not direct the customer to the manufacturer for a remedy. Other markets differ, so check your local rule. Either way, keep the case with one owner.

Does a customer get a loan car?

Rules vary and we did not find a general legal right to one across these markets. Australia's guidance says reasonably foreseeable losses may be recoverable on a major failure. Set a clear written policy, and check local law.

How does Relay know which dealer a complaint is about?

Routing uses the city, area or dealer named in the post and the brand's dealer list, and matches the post to a case. If the post names none, an agent assigns it.

What happens if the dealer ignores the case?

The escalation ladder moves the case up in steps: a reminder, then the escalation desk, then the regional manager, then critical. The brand sets the timings.

Sources

See what Relay can do for your customer service

Get a personalised 30 minute demo on your own channels and policies. We show you Relay handling your real conversations, then set it up with you.

  • Built and connected for you
  • Can run in your own cloud
  • A person on every refund

Brands we work with

  • Bolt
  • Dave & Buster's
  • ETV Win
  • Malachite Cars
  • Space Angel
  • Infinity Quest
Made by Thinkiyo© 2026 Thinkiyo. Relay is a Thinkiyo product.Examples use Lumen Parcel, a fictional brand.